Welcome Brian Fisher,
I understand how frustrating it can be after reinstalling Windows and reconnecting your HDD, BitLocker is asking for the unlock key on every restart.
- Can you confirm if the HDD is set to “Auto-unlock” in BitLocker settings?
- Is this HDD used only as a secondary data drive, or does it contain any system or boot files?
- Have you tried the steps in the previous answer before?
I look forward to your reply so we can continue working together to address the issue.